Nine ways to exit, side by side.
Cash, a Section 453 installment sale, 1031, combinations, Opportunity Zones, deferred sales trust, Delaware statutory trust and a charitable remainder trust, run through the same tax engine on one illustrative sale.
One sale, nine outcomes.
Pick a metric, then tap a scenario for the year-by-year detail. Status shows whether a scenario is computed by the engine, illustrative (engine plus labeled assumptions) or qualitative.
Loading scenarios.
Assumptions and method
- One seller couple, married filing jointly, California residents, both age 66 (senior deduction through 2028 per the engine).
- Commercial building held as a rental (not a real estate professional): gains and rent are subject to the 3.8% net investment income tax.
- Sale price $5,000,000, closing early in 2026 so year 1 is the full 2026 tax year.
- Selling costs $230,500 (engine closingCosts: 4% commission, 0.5% escrow and title, $5,500 county transfer tax).
- Adjusted basis $1,500,000 after $800,000 of straight-line depreciation (all unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, 25% maximum rate; no Section 1245 recapture). Total gain $3,269,500.
- Mortgage $1,000,000 at 6.5%, paid off at closing in every path unless stated.
- Other ordinary income $150,000 a year and Social Security $50,000 a year combined, flat for 20 years (no inflation). No suspended passive losses, no capital loss carryovers.
- Horizon 20 years (2026 through 2045). Anything still held is sold in January 2046 and that tax is subtracted.
- Money not otherwise invested sits in one taxable account earning 5% a year before tax; every year's earnings are taxed as ordinary investment income through the engine (conservative for a stock portfolio). A negative balance means borrowing from other assets at the same 5%.
- Buyer notes: level annual payments, first payment December 2026. Installment and boot notes 6.00% (10 or 20 years); deferred sales trust note 5.25%. The 6.00% notes are above every 2026 AFR (highest long-term: 5.52%, November 2026); the 5.25% trust note is above the 5.12% long-term test rate for a November 2026 contract (lowest of September to November).
- Replacement real estate (1031 and Delaware statutory trust) returns 5% before tax: 3.5% net cash yield after expenses and reserves plus 1.5% yearly growth, the same 5% as the account. New $1M loan at 6.5% interest only.
- Federal and California tax tables: 2026 (Rev. Proc. 2025-32, OBBBA) carried forward unchanged to later years by the engine; California on the FTB 2026 rate schedules (FTB Tax News, October 2026), also carried forward. California's top brackets are kept in every year.
- Taxes shown are the extra tax the sale path causes above the no-sale baseline (other income and Social Security alone).
- Medicare IRMAA surcharges (both spouses, two-year lookback) are reported separately and not included in tax or value.
- Illustrative only, not tax advice. Default risk on buyer notes, fund risk and trust investment risk are not modeled.
Every year 2026 to 2045 is priced with the installment sale tax engine (the Big Sale Tax engine (engine.js)) on that year's whole stack: other income, Social Security, the path's own items (gain by character, note interest, rent, trust payouts, Opportunity Zone inclusions) and the investment account's earnings. Federal regular tax, AMT, NIIT, the senior deduction and California are all from the engine. Cash flows: closing cash earns from closing; note payments, rent and trust payouts arrive at year end; each year's tax is paid at that year's end. "year1_tax" and "deal_tax" exclude tax on the investment account's earnings; "tax" and "total_tax_nominal" include it plus the January 2046 sale of anything still held. "after_tax_value_horizon" = account balance at the end of 2045 + after-tax proceeds of anything still held. Script: ~/sites/bigsaletax/tools/scenarios.js.
Convention: Year-end tax convention: every year's tax, including the year-1 sale tax, is paid at the end of that year (the convention recommended in the 10/1/2026 engine timing audit); closing cash earns from closing. Using one convention for every path keeps the cash sale from being penalized for paying its tax earlier than the others.
Illustrative only. Your numbers will differ. Not tax or legal advice.
The comparisons people search for.
Buy, Borrow, Die vs 1031 Exchange (+ Installment Sale + ILIT): Which Leaves Your Heirs More?
Buy, borrow, die avoids income tax: you never sell, you borrow against the asset, and your heirs get a step-up in basis at death. It does nothing about estate tax, which
ReadDelaware Statutory Trust vs Deferred Sales Trust
They share a short name and nothing else. A Delaware statutory trust is real estate you buy as 1031 replacement property: all gain deferred under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, passi
Read1031 Exchange vs Installment Sale
A 1031 exchange defers all of the gain, but only if you buy like-kind real estate with all of the proceeds within 180 days and stay invested. An installment sale lets you
ReadDeferred Sales Trust vs a Direct Installment Sale
Both spread your gain under Section 453, so the tax math is the same. What differs is who owes you. In a direct installment sale your buyer owes you on a note you secure
ReadOpportunity Zone Fund vs 1031 Exchange
A 1031 exchange defers all of the gain on real estate, but you must reinvest all proceeds and replace the debt in like-kind property. An Opportunity Zone fund takes only
Read1031 Exchange Alternatives: Eight Ways to Sell Real Estate Without a Replacement Property
If you want to keep more of a real estate sale but do not want to buy another property within 180 days, the alternatives are an installment sale (IRC 453), a Section 721
Read721 Exchange vs 1031 Exchange
A 1031 exchange swaps real property for real property and can be repeated, but each exchange has 45-day and 180-day deadlines. A 721 exchange swaps property for operating
Read1031 Exchange vs Taxable Sale: Five Things Owners Miss
A 1031 exchange defers the tax, but it is not free. To defer it all you must buy equal or greater value and replace your debt, so a 3% or 4% loan can become a 7% loan. Su
ReadCharitable Lead Trust vs Charitable Remainder Trust
A charitable remainder trust (CRT) pays you or another person an income stream for life or a term of up to 20 years, then the rest goes to charity. A charitable lead trus
ReadDelaware Statutory Trust + 721 Exchange: How the Combo Works, Pros and Cons
The combination is two steps. First you 1031 into a Delaware statutory trust, which defers the gain under Rev. Rul. 2004-86. Later, the trust's property or your inte
ReadDelaware Statutory Trust vs 721 Exchange: Pros and Cons
A Delaware statutory trust is a 1031 replacement property: the interest counts as real estate under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, so you can keep exchanging. A 721 exchange contribu
ReadInstallment Sale vs Cash Sale: The After-Tax Math
A cash sale puts all the gain in one tax year, often in the top brackets plus the 3.8% net investment income tax. An installment sale taxes gain only as principal arrives
ReadThe four most common paths.
| Cash sale | Installment sale | 1031 exchange | Opportunity Zone | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it defers | Nothing | Gain as payments arrive | Gain reinvested in like-kind real estate | Only the gain you invest, within 180 days |
| Who holds the money | You | The buyer, under your note | Qualified intermediary, then the new property | The Opportunity Zone fund |
| Main trade-off | Biggest one-year tax | Buyer credit risk, managed with security and terms | Must buy real estate, all proceeds and debt | Illiquid, long hold for the full benefit |
| Best fit | Small gain or high basis | Seller willing to be the bank | Owner staying in real estate | Any capital gain, ten-year horizon |
Your Big Sale Options
One page, eleven paths: cash, installment sale, 1031, Delaware statutory trust, Opportunity Zone, charitable remainder trust, Section 121, QSBS, loss harvesting, bracket timing and moving states. What each does, who it fits, the trade-off, liquidity and the 2026 rule, plus four questions for your CPA.
Know your number before you sign.
Start with a free scope call: a short call to see whether the Big Sale Tax Analysis is worth it for your sale. No obligation.
Prefer email? Request the analysis by email.
You talk to Hans Goldstein. Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS.