Big Sale TaxHans Goldstein: Tax & Exit Planning
Home / Tax Tools / Installment sale of rental property
Tax Tool Analysis

Selling a Rental on an Installment Note: Tax Each Year

deferral
Short answerAn installment sale of rental property spreads the gain as the buyer pays, but in a set order: any Section 1245 recapture from cost segregation is taxed in year one, then unrecaptured Section 1250 gain (up to 25%) comes out first from each payment, then capital gain. Passive owners also owe the 3.8% net investment income tax on gain and interest above the threshold.
Year-one tax$356,767
Cash at closing$300,000
Cash left after year-one tax-$56,767

Down payment that just covers year-one tax: $371,366 (12.4%). Recapture income is taxed in the year of sale under Section 453(i); the rest of the gain follows the gross profit ratio, unrecaptured 1250 gain first. Engine: federal, state, NIIT and AMT at 2026 law. Ignores selling costs, interest income and estimated tax timing. Education only.

How an installment sale of rental property works

You sell the rental, the buyer pays part of the price at closing, and you carry a note for the rest, secured by a first-position deed of trust or mortgage on the property. Under installment sale tax rules (IRC 453), each principal payment carries the same gross profit percentage of gain, and the interest is ordinary income. For the general mechanics, see seller-carried note taxes.

A rental is different from raw land because of depreciation. The gain on a rental is taxed in layers, and the installment method moves those layers into a specific order.

The order the gain comes out

  1. Recapture income, year one, all of it. IRC 453(i) pulls Section 1245 recapture and Section 1250 additional depreciation into the year of sale, whatever the buyer pays. For most post-1986 buildings depreciated straight line there is no Section 1250 recapture income. But a cost segregation study moves components into 5-, 7- and 15-year property: depreciation on the 5- and 7-year items is Section 1245 recapture, and bonus or accelerated depreciation on 15-year land improvements is Section 1250 additional depreciation. Both are ordinary income in year one.
  2. Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, first out of each payment. Straight-line depreciation on the building creates gain taxed at up to 25%. It is not recapture income, so it spreads. Treas. Reg. 1.453-12 says it is taken into account before the rest of the capital gain.
  3. Long-term capital gain, last. Taxed at 0%, 15% or 20% depending on income that year.

So early payments carry the 25% layer, and later payments carry the lower rates. The recapture is added to basis for the installment computation, so it is never taxed twice. More detail: depreciation recapture on an installment sale and 1245 vs 1250 recapture.

The 3.8% tax and suspended passive losses

Net investment income tax

For an owner who is not a real estate professional, gain on a rental and interest on the note are net investment income. The 3.8% tax (IRC 1411) applies to the lesser of that income or modified AGI over $250,000 for joint filers ($200,000 single); those thresholds are not indexed. Spreading the gain can keep later years under the threshold, but interest is investment income every year. A real estate professional who meets the 500-hour safe harbor in Treas. Reg. 1.1411-4(g)(7) can exclude the sale gain. The character is fixed in the year of sale and carries to every later payment. See the 3.8% tax on a big sale.

Suspended passive losses

Selling your entire interest in a passive activity to an unrelated buyer frees its suspended losses under IRC 469(g). On an installment sale, Section 469(g)(3) releases them pro rata: each year, the share that year's recognized gain bears to the total gross profit. A cash sale frees them all at once. The release requires the entire activity (if rentals are grouped, selling one building may not qualify), and a sale to a related party does not trigger it.

Worked example (engine-computed)

Assumptions (illustrative): married filing jointly, tax year 2026, $120,000 of other ordinary income, passive owner (not a real estate professional), federal tax only (including alternative minimum tax where the engine finds it). Rental sold for $1,500,000, adjusted basis $500,000, after $400,000 of depreciation: $100,000 on cost-segregated 5- and 7-year components (all recaptured) and $300,000 straight line on the building. Gain $1,000,000: $100,000 Section 1245 recapture, $300,000 unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, $600,000 capital gain. Suspended passive losses: $80,000, released pro rata over a gross profit of $1,000,000. Note: $300,000 down, $1,200,000 at 6%, $120,000 of principal a year for 10 years. Gross profit percentage after recapture: 60%.

Federal tax added by the saleAmountOf which NIIT
Cash sale, no suspended losses$243,861$33,060
Cash sale, all $80,000 of losses released$212,583$30,020
Note, year one ($100,000 recapture plus $180,000 of 1250 gain, $22,400 of losses released)$62,901$4,849
Note, year two ($72,000 of 1250 gain plus $72,000 interest)$29,719$313
Years one to eleven, tax on the gain alone$148,407
Years one to eleven, tax including all interest$241,170

The gain costs $148,407 spread over eleven years against $212,583 in one cash year, and the 3.8% tax nearly disappears after year three. The note also pays $396,000 of interest, which is taxed as received. With zero down, year one would still carry the $100,000 of cost segregation recapture: $18,940 of tax with no cash from the buyer. Engine: yearTax, 2026 brackets from Rev. Proc. 2025-32. State tax not shown. To test your own property, run your numbers.

The mortgage over basis rule

If the buyer assumes your mortgage or takes the property subject to it, the mortgage is not a payment to you, up to your installment sale basis (adjusted basis plus selling costs plus recapture). The part of the mortgage above that basis is treated as a payment in the year of sale (Temp. Treas. Reg. 15a.453-1(b)(3)).

Using the example property: installment sale basis is $500,000 plus $100,000 of recapture, or $600,000. If the buyer takes over a $700,000 mortgage, the $100,000 excess is a year-one payment. Contract price becomes $1,500,000 minus $700,000 plus $100,000, or $900,000, equal to the gross profit, so the gross profit percentage is 100% and every later dollar of principal is all gain. Heavily refinanced rentals hit this often.

Two related points. Cash the buyer uses at closing to pay off your mortgage is a payment to you in the year of sale, not an assumed debt. And most mortgages have due-on-sale clauses, so assumption needs lender consent; a wrap-around mortgage is the other route, with its own lender risk.

1031 exchange vs installment sale on a rental

A 1031 exchange defers all the gain, including recapture on the building, if you buy like-kind real property of equal or greater value and debt. You stay a landlord, and depreciation recapture on cost-segregated components is avoided only to the extent you acquire replacement Section 1245 property. An installment sale ends your landlord role and gives you a note instead, but recapture income is taxed in year one and each payment carries tax.

  • Both: sell, exchange most of the value, and take a buyer's note as boot. Under IRC 453(f)(6) the note's gain is reported as it is paid. See 1031 boot.
  • Failed exchange: if the exchange fails, a qualified intermediary's release of funds in the next tax year may let gain be reported then, but cash cannot later be turned into a note. See failed 1031 exchange.
  • The full comparison: 1031 vs installment sale.

Recapture on an installment sale: how it works, in plain English

Under IRC 453(i), depreciation recapture under Sections 1245 and 1250 is taxed as ordinary income in the year of sale, even if the buyer pays nothing that year. Only the gain above the recapture is spread under the installment method. Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain is different: it is spread with the payments and reported first. Size the down payment to cover the year-1 tax.

An installment sale lets you report gain as the buyer pays you. Section 453(i) carves one piece out of that deferral: recapture income. That is the amount that would be ordinary income under Section 1245 or Section 1250 (or the matching part of Section 751 for a partnership interest) if the whole price were paid in the year of sale. It is reported in full in the year of the sale, whether or not you received a dollar.

  • Step 1. Figure the recapture on Form 4797, Part III, as if it were a cash sale.
  • Step 2. Report that recapture as ordinary income in the year of sale (Form 4797, Part II).
  • Step 3. Add the recapture to your basis for the installment computation. Only the gain above the recapture goes through Form 6252 and is taxed as payments arrive.

The basis step matters. Because the recapture has already been taxed, it is added to basis so the same dollars are not taxed twice. That lowers the gross profit percentage on every later payment.

For recapture on any sale, cash or installment, and a calculator that splits Section 1245 from Section 1250, see the depreciation recapture calculator. This page covers what changes when you carry a note, which is part of how seller-carried note taxes work.

What counts as recapture, and what does not

Counts: Section 1245 recapture

Gain on Section 1245 property is ordinary income up to the depreciation taken. That covers machinery, equipment, vehicles, furniture and fixtures, most purchased intangibles amortized under Section 197, and amounts expensed under Section 179 or bonus depreciation. It also covers the components a cost segregation study moved out of a building into 5-year and 7-year personal property. Those fast write-offs come back as year-1 ordinary income on a sale.

Counts: Section 1250 additional depreciation

For real property, Section 1250 recaptures only additional depreciation: depreciation in excess of straight line. Land improvements and other Section 1250 property depreciated with an accelerated method or bonus depreciation can produce it. Buildings placed in service after 1986 are depreciated straight line, so a plain building sale usually has no Section 1250 recapture income at all.

Does not count: unrecaptured Section 1250 gain

Straight-line depreciation on a building creates unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, taxed at a maximum 25% federal rate. It is not recapture income under 453(i), so it is spread with the payments like other gain. Treas. Reg. 1.453-12 says it is taken into account first, before the 20% gain, as installment payments come in. So early payments on a building sale carry the 25% layer.

A related trap

A sale of depreciable property to a related party can be all ordinary income under Section 1239, and Section 453(g) generally denies the installment method for those sales. See the related-party installment sale analysis.

Recapture on an installment sale: who it fits, and who it does not

  • Hits hardest: owners of trucking, construction, manufacturing, medical and dental practices, restaurants and other equipment-heavy businesses, especially after years of Section 179 and bonus depreciation.
  • Hits hard: real estate owners who ran a cost segregation study and took bonus depreciation on the reclassified components.
  • Hits lightly: sellers of a straight-line building, raw land or a business whose value is mostly goodwill. Most of their gain spreads.
  • Does not apply: a sale with no depreciable property, or gain that is all capital gain on assets never depreciated.

The more of the price that is allocated to depreciated equipment, the bigger the year-1 bill. Buyers usually want more price on equipment (faster write-offs for them); sellers usually want more on goodwill. The purchase price allocation on Form 8594 is where that is decided, and both sides should file consistent numbers.

Recapture on an installment sale: worked example (engine-computed)

Assumptions (illustrative): married filing jointly, tax year 2026, no other income, seller materially participated in the business (so no net investment income tax on the sale gain). Asset sale of an operating business for $3,000,000, no selling costs shown. Equipment: allocated price $900,000, original cost $1,200,000, depreciation taken $1,000,000, adjusted basis $200,000. Goodwill: allocated price $2,100,000, basis $0.

  • Section 1245 recapture: $700,000 (the lesser of the $1,000,000 depreciation or the $700,000 equipment gain).
  • Basis for the installment computation: $200,000 + $700,000 recapture = $900,000.
  • Gross profit: $3,000,000 minus $900,000 = $2,100,000. Gross profit percentage: 70%.
  • So 70 cents of each principal dollar is long-term capital gain, and the $700,000 is taxed in year one regardless.
Year-1 resultFederal tax (no state tax)Federal plus California
Cash sale, all $3,000,000 at closing$611,110$932,311
Installment sale, $0 down$171,269$227,906
Installment sale, $300,000 down (10%)$213,269$290,736
Installment sale, $600,000 down (20%)$255,269$357,311
Down payment that just covers year-1 taxabout $199,149about $288,242

Read the second row twice: with no down payment, the seller owes $171,269 of federal tax in year one with zero cash received. That is the federal tax on the $700,000 of recapture alone. In California the state adds about $56,600 more.

Later years. With 20% down and a $2,400,000 note paid $240,000 a year, each year carries $168,000 of capital gain (70% of $240,000). If the note bears 6% interest (an assumption; the rate must be at least the applicable federal rate), year two also has $144,000 of interest income. The engine puts federal tax for year two at $41,576, including $2,356 of net investment income tax on the interest, with no state tax.

Engine: yearTax with r1245, ltcg and activeBusiness, 2026 brackets from Rev. Proc. 2025-32. State results depend on state rules and change with your facts.

Recapture on an installment sale: how to size the down payment

The year-1 tax has two parts: tax on all the recapture, plus tax on the gross profit percentage times the down payment. A down payment covers the bill when:

Down payment ≥ tax on (recapture + gross profit % × down payment)

Because the recapture is taxed no matter what, the recapture tax is the floor. In the example, any down payment under about $199,149 (federal only) or $288,242 (with California) leaves the seller paying tax out of pocket. Practical rules:

  1. Compute the recapture first, from the actual depreciation schedules and the agreed allocation.
  2. Ask for at least enough cash at closing to pay the year-1 federal and state tax, plus estimated tax timing for that year.
  3. Add a cushion. A larger down payment also gives the buyer more at stake, which protects the note.
  4. Pay attention to estimated taxes. Recapture is income in the quarter of the sale, so plan the safe harbor payments.

The estimator on this page runs the same math. For the full side-by-side, see compare scenarios and the variables explorer.

Recapture on an installment sale: where it goes on the forms

Form and lineWhat goes there
Form 4797, Part III (line 31)Recapture figured as if fully paid in the year of sale
Form 4797, Part IIRecapture reported as ordinary income in the year of sale
Form 6252, line 5Selling price
Form 6252, lines 8 to 10Cost basis, depreciation allowed or allowable, adjusted basis
Form 6252, line 12Income recapture from Form 4797, Part III
Form 6252, line 13Adjusted basis plus selling expenses plus recapture
Form 6252, lines 16 and 19Gross profit and gross profit percentage (after recapture)
Form 6252, line 24Installment sale income for the year (payments times line 19)

For a multi-asset business sale, the IRS treats it as a sale of each asset. Form 8594 reports the allocation, and many preparers file separate Forms 6252 by asset class. IRS Publication 537 includes a worked business-sale example.

Recapture on an installment sale: IRS stance and audit risk

This is settled law, not a planning strategy with gray areas. Section 453(i) has been in the Code since 1984. The audit exposure is in execution:

  • Leaving recapture on the installment schedule. A common error is spreading all the gain, including the recapture. The IRS adjusts it back into the year of sale, with interest and possible penalties.
  • Allocation fights. Seller and buyer Forms 8594 that do not match invite review. An allocation that pushes value away from equipment needs support, such as an appraisal.
  • Missed recapture on cost-segregated components. Reclassified assets must be tracked and recaptured as Section 1245 property.
  • Unrecaptured Section 1250 ordering. Reg. 1.453-12 requires the 25% gain first. Reporting it last understates early-year tax.

Recapture on an installment sale: costs and fees

The rule itself has no fee. The cost is cash: tax due in year one before the buyer has paid much. Other costs are ordinary deal costs: a purchase price allocation study or equipment appraisal if values are contested, your CPA's preparation of Forms 4797, 6252 and 8594, and legal fees to document and secure the note. A modest prepayment of estimated tax can avoid an underpayment penalty for the year of sale.

Protecting the note, costs and IRS stance

Protection: a down payment that covers year-one tax (recapture plus the 1250 layer) and gives the buyer equity; a recorded first-position deed of trust or mortgage; interest at or above the AFR; amortization, any balloon, acceleration, due-on-sale, default and cure terms; the buyer keeps property tax current and the building covered against casualty loss with you named as mortgagee; rent and financial reporting; and a personal guarantee if the buyer is an LLC. If you repossess, Section 1038 limits the gain you recognize; see when the buyer stops paying.

Costs: attorney and escrow fees for the note and deed of trust, a loan servicer if you want one, and your CPA's Forms 6252, 4797 and 8582 each year.

IRS stance: settled law. Errors that draw adjustments: spreading cost segregation recapture, reporting the 25% layer last instead of first, missing the mortgage-over-basis payment, and inadequate stated interest. Notes from the year's sales over $5 million outstanding at year end can trigger the Section 453A interest charge. For every path side by side, Get the full Big Sale Tax Analysis.

What to know

The note spreads the gain, but your money stays tied to the property and the buyer for years, and a buyer who cannot refinance a balloon becomes your problem. Cost segregation and bonus depreciation create recapture that is taxed in year one whatever the buyer pays. Interest is taxed every year and is investment income for the 3.8% tax. Suspended losses are released slowly instead of all at once. If you die holding the note, it does not get a step-up in basis; your heirs owe the remaining tax. States can tax the gain differently, including California, which taxes capital gain as ordinary income.

Recapture is taxed in the year of sale no matter how little the buyer pays at closing, so a low down payment can leave you paying tax from other funds. If the buyer later defaults, you have already paid tax on recapture you may never collect; for personal property there is no Section 1038 repossession relief, so the result runs through bad debt and repossession rules. Price allocation drives the bill, and it must match the buyer's filing. Your CPA should confirm the recapture from the actual depreciation records before the deal terms are set.

Get the full Big Sale Tax Analysis

Free PDF sheet

Debt, Capital Gains and Installment Sales: The Cheat Sheet

Three pages in plain words. One $1,000,000 sale: why paying off the loan does not cut your tax, the debt trap that leaves some sellers short at closing, and the same deal as a lump sum vs an installment sale, plus six traps.

Hans Goldstein
Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS

By entering your email you agree to receive this sheet and occasional educational emails from Hans Goldstein: Tax & Exit Planning. Unsubscribe anytime.

Installment sale + 1031 + ILIT: when is it a slam dunk?

For a large estate, a 1031 exchange, an installment sale and a trust-owned life insurance policy (an ILIT) can work together. It tends to win when most of these are true (2026 figures: the federal estate tax exemption is $15,000,000 per person, $30,000,000 for a married couple):

  1. Your estate is clearly over the line: a projected estate tax bill of $10,000,000 or more.
  2. You are married, age 50 to 60, in preferred health or better. At 75 or older, single, or in a rated health class it usually does not win.
  3. One separate property has stuck (suspended) passive losses at least as big as its gain.
  4. That property earns little: low cap rate, slow growth.
  5. You would sell or borrow anyway, or you do not have the cash on hand to pay the premiums.

Four or five true? Run the numbers. Enter your own estate and ages below, or open the full calculator. Estimates from published rates, not a quote or advice; your CPA and attorney decide.

Open the calculator on this page

Frequently asked questions

Can I do an installment sale on a rental property?
Yes. A rental is eligible for the installment method under IRC 453 unless you are a dealer in real property. You report gain as principal is paid, except recapture income, which is taxed in the year of sale.
Is depreciation recapture taxed in year one on a rental installment sale?
Section 1245 recapture (for example on cost-segregated components) and Section 1250 additional depreciation are taxed in year one under 453(i). Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain from straight-line building depreciation is spread, but it comes out of the first payments, before the lower-rate gain.
Does the 3.8% net investment income tax apply to an installment sale of a rental?
For a passive owner, yes, on both the gain and the interest, in each year your modified AGI exceeds $250,000 joint or $200,000 single. Spreading the gain can lower or remove it in later years. A real estate professional who meets the 500-hour safe harbor can exclude the gain.
What happens to my suspended passive losses on an installment sale?
If you sell your entire interest in the activity to an unrelated buyer, the losses are released each year in proportion to the gain recognized that year over total gross profit (IRC 469(g)(3)). A cash sale releases them all in the year of sale.
What if my mortgage is more than my basis?
If the buyer assumes it or takes subject to it, the excess of the mortgage over your installment sale basis is treated as a payment in the year of sale, and the gross profit percentage on the rest becomes 100%. If the buyer's cash pays it off at closing, the whole payoff is a year-one payment.
Can I combine a 1031 exchange with an installment sale?
Yes. You can exchange part of the value into like-kind property and take the buyer's note as boot. The note's gain is reported as it is paid under IRC 453(f)(6), and the like-kind portion stays deferred.
Is the interest on a rental installment note taxable?
Yes. It is ordinary income in the year received and generally counts as net investment income. It is portfolio income, not passive income, so suspended passive losses cannot offset it until they are released.
What is depreciation recapture and how does it affect seller-carried note tax treatment?
Recapture is the part of your gain that comes from depreciation you already deducted. On a seller-carried sale, ordinary recapture under Sections 1245 and 1250 is taxed in full in the year of sale even if the buyer pays little or nothing down (IRC 453(i)), so it shrinks the gain you can spread and should be covered by the down payment.
Is depreciation recapture taxed in the year of an installment sale?
Yes. IRC 453(i) requires all Section 1245 and Section 1250 recapture income to be recognized in the year of sale, even if no payment is received that year. Only the gain above the recapture is reported as payments come in.
Is it 1245 or 1250 recapture?
It depends on the asset. Section 1245 covers equipment, vehicles, furniture, cost-segregated personal property components and amortized intangibles such as purchased goodwill: all the depreciation or amortization is ordinary recapture, taxed in the year of sale. Section 1250 covers buildings: for buildings depreciated straight line there is usually no ordinary recapture, and the straight-line depreciation is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, taxed at up to 25% and spread with the payments. Only depreciation above straight line, such as bonus depreciation on land improvements, is Section 1250 ordinary recapture in year one. The depreciation recapture calculator splits the two.
Can I spread unrecaptured Section 1250 gain on an installment sale?
Yes. Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain (from straight-line depreciation on buildings) is not recapture income under 453(i). It is spread with the payments, but Treas. Reg. 1.453-12 says it is reported first, before gain taxed at the lower capital gain rates.
How does recapture change the gross profit percentage?
The recapture is added to your basis on Form 6252 (line 12), so it is not taxed twice. That reduces gross profit and the gross profit percentage used for every later payment.
How big should my down payment be?
At least enough to pay the year-1 tax: the tax on all the recapture plus the tax on the gross profit percentage times the down payment. In our $3,000,000 example with $700,000 of recapture, that was about $199,149 federal only, or about $288,242 with California tax.
Does cost segregation make recapture worse on an installment sale?
It can. Components reclassified as 5-year or 7-year personal property are Section 1245 property, so the depreciation on them is recaptured as ordinary income in the year of sale. Bonus depreciation on land improvements can also create Section 1250 additional depreciation.
Is recapture subject to the net investment income tax?
It depends on your role. Gain on assets of a business in which you materially participate is generally excluded from net investment income. Gain on a passive rental or investment is generally included. Interest on the note is generally investment income.
Can I avoid recapture by selling stock instead of assets?
A stock sale of a corporation generally produces capital gain at the shareholder level with no recapture, which is why buyers and sellers negotiate structure. That changes if the buyer and seller make a Section 338(h)(10) or 336(e) election, which treats the stock sale as an asset sale. For a partnership or LLC interest, Section 751 still taxes the recapture share as ordinary income. Model both before agreeing.
How Hans helps: the Big Sale Tax Analysis models this path side by side with every other option for your sale and ends with a written recommendation. See the analysis.
Next step

Know your number before you sign.

Start with a free scope call: a short call to see whether the Big Sale Tax Analysis is worth it for your sale. No obligation.

Prefer email? Request the analysis by email.

You talk to Hans Goldstein. Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS.

Call Hans: 213-340-2018Book a time