Three ways timber leaves your land, three tax results
Timber owners sell in one of three ways, and the Code handles each differently:
- Lump-sum (outright) sale of standing timber. You sell all the designated trees for a fixed price, usually after a sealed-bid sale run by a consulting forester. If you held the timber more than one year, the price minus your depletion basis is treated as gain on the sale of timber under IRC 631(b), and it is Section 1231 gain or capital gain depending on whether you hold the land in a business. The sale date is the disposal date.
- Pay-as-cut contract. The buyer pays per ton or per thousand board feet as trees are removed, and you keep an economic interest. Same 631(b) treatment, but the disposal date is the date each tree is cut, so gain falls in the tax year of cutting (IRC 631(b)).
- Cutting it yourself. If you harvest and sell logs or lumber, the profit is ordinary business income unless you elect under IRC 631(a). The election treats the cutting as a sale: the timber's fair market value on the first day of the tax year, minus depletion basis, is 1231 gain, and that value becomes your cost for the later log sale.
Long-term gain is taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, the top rate starting at $613,700 of taxable income for joint filers (Rev. Proc. 2025-32, 2026); the full table is on the capital gains hub. Georgia, our example state, adds a flat 4.99% in 2026 (Georgia DOR) with no timber-specific income tax break.
Depletion basis: the number most owners leave blank
You do not pay tax on the whole check, only on the amount above the basis of the timber you sold. That basis lives in a timber account. When you bought or inherited the land, its cost or date-of-death value should have been split among bare land, merchantable timber, young timber and improvements by relative value. The timber account is then turned into a per-unit rate: depletion unit = adjusted basis in the account divided by total timber volume. IRS Publication 225 (2025 edition) walks through a tract with $24,000 of timber basis and 300,000 units, a depletion unit of $0.08; cutting 27,000 units yields $2,160 of depletion.
Inherited land is where this pays most. In our example the heirs commissioned a retrospective cruise valuing the merchantable pine at the date of death, which gave them $60,000 of basis to deduct. Without that work many owners report the entire sale price as gain. A forester can reconstruct basis years later, but it is harder and less defensible.
The 631(a) election for owners who log
A landowner who cuts his own timber and sells logs has ordinary income on the whole margin unless he elects 631(a). In our example the election changes the federal income tax by $30,433: the same $340,000 of stumpage value is taxed at long-term rates instead of ordinary rates. The logging margin above stumpage stays ordinary either way.
The election requires that you owned the timber, or held the contract right to cut it, for more than one year before cutting. It covers all timber you own or have a right to cut, and it binds you for later years unless the IRS permits a revocation for undue hardship (IRC 631(a)). Because the gain is measured on January 1 values, a sawmill owner in a falling market can lock in a higher stumpage figure than the logs eventually fetch, and the gap becomes an ordinary loss on the log sale.
Lump sum or pay-as-cut: timing and risk
The two contract forms produce the same character of gain but different timing. A lump-sum sale puts all the gain in the year you sign and are paid. A pay-as-cut contract spreads it over the years the logger actually works. In our example the lump sum adds $74,281 of tax and the two-year pay-as-cut adds $67,676, a difference of $6,605, mostly because less gain is exposed to the 3.8% investment income tax under IRC 1411 (2026 threshold $250,000 for joint filers, not indexed) in each year.
Pay-as-cut has trade-offs on the ground: volumes are measured at the mill, so you need scale tickets and an honest buyer, and a wet season or a mill closure can push cutting into a year you did not plan. Many foresters prefer lump-sum sales because the buyer bears the volume risk. If you want lump-sum certainty and spread tax, a lump-sum price paid partly on a secured note can be reported on the installment method, since timber is not inventory for an investor.
Reforestation costs and their recapture
Replanting is the one timber cost the Code rewards quickly. Under IRC 194, each owner can deduct up to $10,000 of reforestation costs per qualified timber property each year ($5,000 if married filing separately), and amortize the rest over 84 months beginning in the second half of the year the costs are incurred (IRC 194(a), (b), unchanged for 2026). Site preparation, seedlings and planting labor qualify.
The catch arrives at harvest. Those deductions and amortization are treated like depreciation for recapture: if you sell the timber property within roughly 10 years, gain up to the 194 deductions is ordinary income under IRC 1245, with amounts tied to basis acquired before the 10th preceding tax year excluded (IRC 1245(b)(7)). Pine thinned at year 12 to 15 usually escapes; a quick resale of a freshly replanted tract does not.
Paperwork, the investment income tax and where Hans helps
Form T (Timber) must be filed for any year you claim depletion, make the 631(a) election, or make an outright sale under 631(b), unless you only have an occasional sale, which the instructions define as one or two sales every 3 or 4 years (Instructions for Form T). Sales go on Form 4797 if you hold timber in a trade or business and on Schedule D if you are an investor.
Investors owe the 3.8% net investment income tax on timber gain above the threshold, as our first example shows ($7,980). An owner who materially participates in a timber business is outside it on gain from property used in that business. A large harvest can also be paired with loss harvesting, a 1031 exchange of the land and timber together into other real property, or a charitable remainder trust. Get the Big Sale Tax Analysis at /analysis/ to model a lump sum, a pay-as-cut contract and an installment note side by side.
What to know
Depletion basis you cannot document will be challenged, so keep the cruise, the allocation and Form T history. The 631(a) election is sticky and covers all your timber. Pay-as-cut spreads gain but leaves volume and timing risk with you. Reforestation deductions can come back as ordinary income on an early sale. State severance or yield taxes on harvests are separate from income tax.
Worked example
Married couple sells all merchantable pine on an inherited tract for $400,000 to a timber buyer; $60,000 depletion basis from a date-of-death cruise; $120,000 of other income; they do not run a timber business. A landowner who runs his own logging business cuts the same timber and sells logs; $340,000 of stumpage value over depletion basis is ordinary business income (logging profit above stumpage is ignored here). Same harvest, but the owner elects 631(a): the $340,000 excess of January 1 fair market value of the timber cut over its depletion basis becomes Section 1231 gain. Same investor sells on a pay-per-ton contract; the logger cuts half in late 2026 and half in 2027, so $170,000 of gain is reported each year.
| Engine run | Lump-sum sale of standing pine, Georgia investor | Owner logs it himself, no 631(a) election | Same owner, Section 631(a) election made | Investor, pay-as-cut contract spanning two years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Filing status | Married, joint | Married, joint | Married, joint | Married, joint |
| State | Georgia | Georgia | Georgia | Georgia |
| Tax years | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 |
| Other income (wages, pension, interest) per year | $120,000 | $120,000 | $120,000 | $120,000 |
| Long-term capital gain | $340,000 | $0 | $340,000 | $340,000 |
| Ordinary income from the sale (short-term gain, inventory, non-compete) | $0 | $340,000 | $0 | $0 |
| Federal income tax on the sale | $49,335 | $79,768 | $49,335 | $47,670 |
| Net investment income tax (3.8%) | $7,980 | $7,980 | $0 | $3,040 |
| State income tax on the sale | $16,966 | $16,966 | $16,966 | $16,966 |
| Total tax caused by the sale | $74,281 | $104,714 | $66,301 | $67,676 |
| Effective rate on the gain | 21.8% | 30.8% | 19.5% | 19.9% |
| Gain kept after these taxes | $265,719 | $235,286 | $273,699 | $272,324 |
Computed October 7, 2026 by the Big Sale Tax engine (engine.js yearTax): federal brackets, 0/15/20% thresholds and AMT from Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (OBBBA-adjusted) and the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (P.L. 119-21); NIIT under IRC 1411 (thresholds not indexed); state tax from the engine's state table. "Tax caused by the sale" = tax with the sale minus tax without it. Excludes selling costs, local taxes and estimated-tax timing. Education only.
Run your own numbers
2026 law from the engine: federal 0/15/20% brackets (Rev. Proc. 2025-32), 25% cap on unrecaptured 1250 gain, ordinary rates on 1245 recapture, 3.8% NIIT over $200,000 single / $250,000 joint (IRC 1411), AMT, and your state's rules. Tax shown is the tax caused by the sale. Excludes selling costs, local taxes and NIIT exceptions for active business owners. Education only.
Long-Term vs Short-Term Capital Gains (2026)
The one-year holding rule, the 2026 0/15/20% thresholds for every filing status, NIIT, recapture, the state layer and a worked $200,000 example: 11 months vs 13 months, and what spreading the gain can save.
Frequently asked questions
Is selling timber taxed as capital gains?
How do I calculate timber depletion?
Do I have to file Form T for a timber sale?
Is a lump-sum or pay-as-cut timber sale better for taxes?
Do I pay self-employment tax on timber sales?
Can I deduct the cost of replanting trees?
Sources
- IRC 631, timber gain (Cornell LII)
- IRC 194, reforestation (Cornell LII)
- IRC 611, depletion (Cornell LII)
- IRC 1245 (Cornell LII)
- IRC 1411 (Cornell LII)
- IRS Publication 225, Farmer's Tax Guide
- Instructions for Form T (Timber), IRS
- Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (IRS)
- Georgia DOR, income tax rate update
Figures as of October 7, 2026; each rate and limit above names its source and year. Education only, not legal or tax advice.
Keep reading
Farmland
A farm sale is five tax sales at once, and whether you cash rent or farm the ground decides the 3.8% layer.
ReadLand sale
Raw land has no depreciation to recapture, so the big question is whether the IRS sees you as an investor or a dealer.
ReadSection 1231 gain
Why business real estate, equipment and goodwill end up at long-term rates, how netting and the five-year lookback work, and where recapture cuts in first.
ReadConservation easement
Sell it, donate it or split the difference: each path taxes your farm's development rights differently.
ReadInstallment sale (Section 453)
Report the gain as the buyer pays you instead of all in the year of sale, under rules that have been in the tax code for decades.
Read1031 exchange
Defer the whole gain by trading investment real estate for more real estate, if you can find it and close inside 180 days.
ReadKnow your number before you sign.
The Big Sale Tax Analysis is a flat $5,000. Start with a free scoping call; you are invoiced only after it, and only if you go ahead.
Prefer email? Request the analysis by email.