How it works (as marketed)
The Federal Register describes the typical transaction this way (88 FR 51756):
- The seller, who already has a buyer at a set price, sells the property to an intermediary, often tied to the promoter, for an installment note that pays interest only, with principal due in a balloon after many years.
- The intermediary immediately resells the property to the real buyer for cash, at about the same price.
- The intermediary deposits the buyer's cash, less fees, into an account with a third-party lender.
- The lender makes a nonrecourse loan to the seller of about the same amount, funded or secured by that account. The seller's loan payments are limited to what the intermediary pays on the note.
- When the note matures, the note, loan and account offset, and the seller reports the gain then.
The pitch: the seller has nearly all the cash on day one and pays tax in 30 years.
IRS stance and audit risk
The IRS has taken the position, repeatedly and in writing, that the structure does not defer gain:
- Chief Counsel Advice 202118016, released May 7, 2021, agreed that "the theory on which promoters base the arrangements is flawed" and listed problems: no genuine debt, debt secured by the escrow, the economic benefit doctrine, the Section 453A(d) pledge rule and the step transaction doctrine (CCA 202118016).
- Dirty Dozen. The IRS put monetized installment sales on its 2023 Dirty Dozen list of schemes (IR-2023-65).
- Proposed listed transaction. On August 4, 2023 Treasury and the IRS proposed Prop. Treas. Reg. 1.6011-13 (REG-109348-22) to identify monetized installment sales and substantially similar transactions as listed transactions. The preamble says the intermediary is not a bona fide buyer, citing Court Holding, and that the seller has received full payment, either because the note is indirectly secured by the sale cash (Temp. Treas. Reg. 15a.453-1(b)(3)(i)) or because the loan proceeds are themselves a payment.
- Status. As of October 2026 the Federal Register shows only the proposed rule and an October 11, 2023 notice cancelling the public hearing; no final rule. A federal district court in Idaho dismissed a promoter's challenge to the proposal, holding that a proposed rule is not final agency action. Listed status starts when final regulations are published, and the proposal would then require disclosure for prior years still open for assessment.
Even before a final rule, the government challenges these deals on the merits. In April 2025 the Justice Department asked a federal court in Idaho to bar a promoter from selling them, alleging about 386 transactions with reported sales over $968 million since 2015, according to published reports of the complaint.
Penalties if it is recast
- The tax itself. The full gain is taxed in the year of the sale, with interest from the original due date.
- Accuracy penalty. 20% of a reportable transaction understatement, 30% if the transaction was not properly disclosed (IRC 6662A).
- Failure to disclose a listed transaction (once listed): 75% of the tax decrease, at least $5,000 and at most $100,000 for an individual for each failure (IRC 6707A). Material advisors have their own disclosure and list-keeping duties.
- Longer exposure. Undisclosed listed transactions can keep the assessment period open (IRC 6501(c)(10)).
Worked example
Assumptions (illustrative): married couple filing jointly, $150,000 of other income, 2026 tables, a $5,000,000 long-term gain. Taxes from the sale computed with the Big Sale Tax engine.
| Texas | California | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax on the gain in the year of sale (what the IRS says is due) | $1,185,065 | $1,813,169 |
| Tax the promoter's return reports for the year of sale | $0 on the gain | $0 on the gain |
If the transaction is recast, the first row is due for the sale year, plus interest and the penalties above, and the seller has already spent the fees and taken on a loan.
Who it fits, and who it does not
It fits no one Hans works with. A seller who wants cash at closing and lower tax is better served by a model of the lawful options: a cash sale with planning around timing and losses, a 1031 exchange, an Opportunity Zone investment, a charitable remainder trust, or a real installment sale where the seller accepts receiving the money over time.
Costs and fees
Sellers pay fees to the intermediary and the lender, often bear a spread between the loan rate and the note rate, and pay legal costs. The Federal Register preamble notes that the fees are "substantially less than the Federal tax savings purportedly achieved," which is why the transaction is sold. If the deferral fails, the fees are gone and the tax is still due.
How it compares with a Section 453 installment sale
| Monetized installment sale | Section 453 installment sale (seller-carried note) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who buys | An intermediary that resells at once | The real buyer |
| Loan to the seller | Yes, for about the full price | None |
| Cash at closing | Nearly all, through the loan | The down payment only |
| When gain is taxed | Claimed: at maturity. IRS: year of sale | As principal payments arrive (IRC 453) |
| IRS status | Proposed listed transaction | Settled law since 1926 |
The difference is economic: in a real installment sale you wait for your money and carry the buyer's credit, which you manage with a down payment, a first-position lien, a personal guarantee from the buyer's owners and strong note terms.
The deferral is the reward for actually deferring the cash. See installment sale, seller-carried note and the Section 453A pledge rule, which treats borrowing against a note as payment.
Monetized installment sale vs deferred sales trust
Both use an intermediary between you and the buyer, which is why they get confused. The difference is the loan.
| Monetized installment sale | Deferred sales trust | |
|---|---|---|
| Intermediary | A dealer that buys and immediately resells | A third-party trust that sells and invests the cash |
| Cash to you at closing | Nearly all of it, through a loan | None beyond any agreed down payment; you are paid on the note over time |
| Where the cash sits | In escrow, effectively securing the loan | Invested by the trustee |
| IRS status | Proposed listed transaction (REG-109348-22); Chief Counsel says the loan is a payment | Not listed and not a transaction of interest, but no published ruling approves it |
| Main risk | The whole gain taxed in the sale year, plus interest and penalties | Trustee independence, portfolio performance and fees |
A deferred sales trust that lends you money or lets you pledge the note starts to look like the monetized version. See the deferred sales trust analysis.
What to know
The monetized installment sale asks you to believe you can have the money now and the tax later. The IRS Chief Counsel, the 2023 Dirty Dozen list and a pending listed transaction proposal all say otherwise.
If the IRS recasts the deal, the whole gain is taxed in the sale year with interest and penalties, after the fees are paid. Hans does not offer it, and recommends having your own CPA or tax attorney review any version you are shown, including ones sold under a different name.
Debt, Capital Gains and Installment Sales: The Cheat Sheet
Three pages in plain words. One $1,000,000 sale: why paying off the loan does not cut your tax, the debt trap that leaves some sellers short at closing, and the same deal as a lump sum vs an installment sale, plus six traps.
Installment sale + 1031 + ILIT: when is it a slam dunk?
For a large estate, a 1031 exchange, an installment sale and a trust-owned life insurance policy (an ILIT) can work together. It tends to win when most of these are true (2026 figures: the federal estate tax exemption is $15,000,000 per person, $30,000,000 for a married couple):
- Your estate is clearly over the line: a projected estate tax bill of $10,000,000 or more.
- You are married, age 50 to 60, in preferred health or better. At 75 or older, single, or in a rated health class it usually does not win.
- One separate property has stuck (suspended) passive losses at least as big as its gain.
- That property earns little: low cap rate, slow growth.
- You would sell or borrow anyway, or you do not have the cash on hand to pay the premiums.
Four or five true? Run the numbers. Enter your own estate and ages below, or open the full calculator. Estimates from published rates, not a quote or advice; your CPA and attorney decide.
Open the calculator on this page
Frequently asked questions
Is a monetized installment sale legit?
Is the monetized installment sale a listed transaction now?
What is the REG number for the monetized installment sale regulations?
What penalties apply?
How is it different from a normal installment sale?
Can I borrow against a normal installment note?
Sources
- Proposed listed transaction, 88 FR 51756 (Federal Register)
- Hearing cancellation, Oct. 11, 2023 (Federal Register)
- Chief Counsel Advice 202118016 (IRS)
- IR-2023-65 Dirty Dozen (IRS)
- Temp. Treas. Reg. 15a.453-1 (eCFR)
- IRC 453A(d) pledge rule (Cornell LII)
- IRC 6707A (Cornell LII)
- IRC 6662A (Cornell LII)
Updated November 13, 2026. Education only, not legal or tax advice.
Keep comparing
Section 453A interest charge
Installment notes over $5 million carry a yearly interest charge on the deferred tax; here is the formula, a calculator and the exceptions.
ReadInstallment sale (Section 453)
Report the gain as the buyer pays you instead of all in the year of sale, under rules that have been in the tax code for decades.
ReadSeller-carried note
Carry the buyer's note, collect interest, and pay the tax as the principal comes in, with the right collateral and terms behind it.
ReadSection 453A pledge rule
Borrowing against your installment note can trigger the deferred tax early; here is exactly when, how much, and who is exempt.
ReadDeferred sales trust
A branded installment sale to a third-party trust: how it works under Section 453, what it costs, and where the IRS could attack it.
ReadDeferred Sales Trust vs a Direct Installment Sale
Both spread your gain under Section 453, so the tax math is the same. What differs is who owes you. In a direct installment sale your buyer
ReadKnow your number before you sign.
Start with a free scope call: a short call to see whether the Big Sale Tax Analysis is worth it for your sale. No obligation.
Prefer email? Request the analysis by email.
You talk to Hans Goldstein. Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS.