Big Sale TaxHans Goldstein: Tax & Exit Planning
Home / Compare / Charitable UPREIT vs Charitable Remainder Trust vs Outright Gift
Compare: charitable UPREIT, charitable remainder trust, outright gift

Charitable UPREIT vs Charitable Remainder Trust vs Outright Gift

Short answerA charitable UPREIT is a 1031 exchange with the option to give later: the tax benefit at the sale is ordinary 1031 deferral, and the charitable benefit arises only when appreciated trust interests or units are given after a real holding period. Three ways to use a big real estate gain for charity: give the property outright, fund a charitable remainder trust, or use a charitable UPREIT. An outright gift of long-term appreciated real estate to a public charity is deductible at fair market value with no tax on the gain, but you keep nothing and most charities will not take a mortgaged or risky property. A charitable UPREIT is a 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust, a 721 contribution into UPREIT operating partnership units, and then a gift of units, or part of an interest, to charity. A charitable remainder trust (CRT) sells your property tax-exempt, pays you income for life or up to 20 years, and leaves what remains to charity; you get a partial deduction and the gain is taxed to you as the income arrives. The 1031 and 721 steps keep the gain deferred and can replace a mortgage, but they end future exchanges and make unit redemptions taxable, and the gift step needs a qualified appraisal and a charity willing to accept units. Which fits depends on debt, heirs, control and how charitable you really are.

Request the analysis Book a free scope call

Tax mechanics only: this page explains how the tax works and what it costs. It does not recommend buying, holding or avoiding any security, fund, sponsor or offering. Hans is not a CPA, attorney or registered investment adviser.
Outright gift of real estateCharitable remainder trustCharitable UPREIT (1031, 721, then gift)
What you doGive the property itself to a public charity, with no sale firstFund an irrevocable trust with the property before a binding sale; the trustee sells1031 into a Delaware statutory trust, 721 into operating partnership units, then give units or an undivided share
Capital gain on the giftNone: gain is never taxed on the property givenNone at the sale if the trust, not you, is the seller; gain taxed to you as payments carry out income (IRC 664(b))None on the part given; deferred until redemption on the part you keep
Income tax deductionFair market value of long-term property, with no related-use test for real estate; 30% of AGI, or 50% if you elect basis; 5-year carryforwardPresent value of the charity's remainder, within AGI limitsFair market value of the units or interest given, within 30% of AGI
Income to youNone; you keep nothingYes, for life or up to 20 yearsDistributions on what you keep; none on what you give
MortgagePart sale, part gift (bargain sale, IRC 170(e)(2)); most charities decline debtPoor fit: debt can cause bargain-sale income, self-dealing and unrelated business incomeThe trust's loan can replace the debt; a gift of a leveraged interest is also a bargain sale
What the charity must acceptReal estate, with environmental and carrying cost riskNothing until the trust endsA security (trust interest or units) that is illiquid
HeirsAsset gone from the estateRemainder goes to charity; heirs get nothing from itPart you keep can pass with a stepped-up basis (IRC 1014)
Timing riskA binding sale before the gift makes the gain yours (assignment of income)Fund before a binding sale (Blake, Ferguson)A gift planned before the exchange closes can undercut intent to hold; 45 and 180 day clocks apply to step 1
Control and liquidityNone after the giftTrustee runs the portfolio; irrevocableAlmost none; sponsor sets financing and sale date; redemption limits
Main risksCharity refuses; debt; prearranged sale; private foundation limitsPrearranged sale, UBTI excise tax, irrevocability, 2026 deduction trims, costsFees, illiquidity, appraisal, charity acceptance, taxable exit on the part you keep

Talk to Hans before you pick one

These strategies are complex, and the right one depends on your numbers. Debt, basis, depreciation, your income, your heirs and which charity will actually accept the gift each change the answer. Book a free scope call with Hans to see whether the $5,000 Big Sale Tax Analysis is worth it for your sale, or request the analysis. Want the overview first? Get the Big Sale Options sheet by email (form further down this page).

What is a charitable UPREIT?

A charitable UPREIT is a plan in three steps. First, you sell and 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust interest, which is a security, not the real estate itself. Second, the trust's property or your interest is contributed to a REIT's operating partnership for units under IRC 721, the 721 UPREIT step.

Third, you give the units, or an undivided share of them, to charity. The idea is that a charity that would turn down a gas station, a building or land can often accept a security, and you keep the deferral until the gift.

Because the gift of long-term appreciated property is generally deductible at fair market value, the deferred gain is never taxed to you on the part you give.

This page compares that plan with an outright gift of the real estate and with a charitable remainder trust, the more familiar route for a charitable seller.

What about simply giving the real estate to charity?

This is the baseline. Unlike art given to a museum, real estate has no related-use test.

The rule that cuts a deduction to your basis when a charity does not use tangible personal property for its mission (IRC 170(e)(1)(B)(i)), and the three-year recapture on a quick resale (IRC 170(e)(7), Form 8282), apply to tangible personal property, not real property.

A long-term appreciated building or parcel given to a public charity is deductible at fair market value whatever the charity does with it. You owe no capital gain. The limit is 30% of adjusted gross income (or 50% if you elect to deduct basis instead), and unused amounts carry forward five years. A qualified appraisal and Form 8283 Section B are required.

Pitfalls. A mortgage makes the gift a bargain sale, so you recognize gain on the portion treated as sold (IRC 170(e)(2); Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2), and charities rarely accept debt. If a sale is already binding or practically certain, the gain is taxed to you under assignment of income.

A private foundation gets a basis deduction and a 20% AGI limit. Many charities refuse property because of environmental and carrying costs, and you keep nothing. That refusal is what the other two paths try to solve.

What is actually charitable about a charitable UPREIT?

It helps to be precise. A charitable UPREIT is a 1031 exchange with the option to give later. At the sale, the tax benefit is ordinary 1031 deferral. The charitable benefit arises only if you later give appreciated Delaware statutory trust interests, operating partnership units or an undivided share of them to charity. Until then it is a deferral plan, with its costs and risks.

  • Held-for-investment intent. IRC 1031(a)(1) requires that you hold the replacement property for investment or business use. A gift soon after the exchange invites the argument that you never intended to hold it. There is no bright-line holding period; many advisers look for a real holding period, often cited as two years by analogy to IRC 1031(f), which is a convention, not a rule.
  • Debt. Giving a leveraged trust interest or units is a bargain sale on the debt relief (Rev. Rul. 75-194; Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2), so part of the gain is recognized. The charity may also have unrelated business income on debt-financed property (IRC 514).
  • Appraisal and acceptance. Illiquid interests need a qualified appraisal, and valuation discounts can shrink the deduction. Many charities and donor-advised fund sponsors will not accept partnership or trust interests.
  • Why the exchange first. A charity is tax-exempt and has no use for a 1031 exchange. Its objection to real estate is liability and expertise. The structure works only when the donor exchanges first and gives a security later.
  • Costs. Sponsor loads and commissions, illiquidity, and conversion triggers on units can all reduce the value that reaches you or the charity.

Which problem is each one solving?

A charitable remainder trust and a 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust are often pitched to the same seller, but they answer different questions. The trust asks: do I want income now and a gift to charity later?

The exchange asks: do I want to keep owning real estate and keep it in the family? The 721 UPREIT step asks: do I want out of managing property and out of repeated deadlines, even if it means giving up future exchanges?

The honest first filter is how charitable you are. If leaving something meaningful to charity is already part of the plan, a CRT, or a gift of trust interests, is worth modeling. If it is not, a CRT is an expensive way to disinherit your children, and the 1031 path or an installment sale usually wins.

How does a charitable remainder trust work for a seller?

You sign an irrevocable trust, fund it with the appreciated property before a binding sale, and the trustee sells. The trust is exempt from income tax (IRC 664(c)), so the whole price is reinvested.

You are paid a fixed percentage or amount, 5% to 50% a year, for life or up to 20 years, and the remainder goes to the charities you name. The remainder must be worth at least 10% of the value placed in the trust at funding (IRC 664(d)).

How the payments are taxed. Each payment carries out the trust's income in four tiers (IRC 664(b)): ordinary income first, then capital gain, then other income such as tax-exempt interest, then return of principal. Your big sale gain sits in the capital gain tier and is taxed to you as it is paid out, not all at once. The net investment income tax can apply to those payments.

The deduction. You deduct the present value of the charity's remainder in the year you fund the trust, using the IRC 7520 rate. Gifts of long-term appreciated property to a public charity are limited to 30% of adjusted gross income, or 20% if a private non-operating foundation is the remainder beneficiary, with a five-year carryforward.

Starting in 2026, charitable deductions count only above 0.5% of the contribution base, and taxpayers in the 37% bracket have itemized deductions reduced by 2/37 (IRC 68), so the deduction is worth less than it was.

When does a CRT break down?

Prearranged sales. The trust saves tax only if the trust is the seller. If a sale was already binding or practically certain when you transferred the property, the IRS can tax the gain to you under the assignment of income doctrine.

Blake v. Commissioner (2d Cir. 1982) and Ferguson v. Commissioner (9th Cir. 1999) went against taxpayers; Palmer v. Commissioner (1974) and Rev. Rul. 78-197 allow a gift when the charity is not legally bound to sell.

Debt. A mortgage on the contributed property can produce bargain-sale income, self-dealing issues (the private foundation rules apply through IRC 4947(a)(2)) and unrelated business income. Unrelated business taxable income inside a CRT triggers a 100% excise tax on that income (IRC 664(c)(2)). Paying the debt off first, or choosing another path, is the usual answer.

Heirs. The asset leaves your estate and the remainder goes to charity. Some families pair a CRT with a wealth replacement irrevocable life insurance trust so heirs are not shortchanged; that adds cost and underwriting, and the Big Sale Tax Analysis does not recommend a product.

How does a 1031 into a Delaware statutory trust compare?

A beneficial interest in a qualifying Delaware statutory trust is treated as an interest in real estate for 1031 purposes under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, so you can sell through a qualified intermediary, identify the interest within 45 days and close within 180 days.

Any cash or debt not replaced is boot and is taxed. Because the trust takes on a loan, the trust's financing can replace a mortgage that a CRT could not accept.

Pros: the gain and depreciation recapture are deferred; passive ownership; fractional amounts that let you match your proceeds; useful as a day-45 backup when a primary replacement property falls through; and heirs can receive a stepped-up basis at death (IRC 1014), which can erase the deferred gain.

Cons: sponsor and selling fees reduce what is invested and are charged again at each reinvestment; no public market and no say in when it sells; the trustee cannot renegotiate leases or raise new capital; generally limited to accredited investors; and when you cash out, the deferred gain comes due.

These are securities offerings, so read the private placement memorandum with your own advisers. See Delaware statutory trust vs 721 exchange for the full comparison.

What changes with a 721 UPREIT contribution?

Some offerings let the sponsor's REIT operating partnership acquire the trust's property, or your interest, for units under IRC 721. That avoids a new 45-day and 180-day clock and gives a share of a portfolio.

The price is that units are not like-kind real property, so you can never 1031 again, redeeming units for cash or shares is taxable (IRC 731, 741), your built-in gain stays yours under IRC 704(c), and a drop in your share of partnership debt can be taxed.

A later sale of units can therefore be a taxable event years after the exchange. See 721 UPREIT.

Can a charitable seller combine these?

Two combinations come up. Both are advanced and should be reviewed by your attorney and CPA before anything is signed.

Give trust interests or units to charity (the charitable UPREIT gift step). An outright gift of long-term appreciated property to a public charity is generally deductible at fair market value, within the 30% of AGI limit, and the gain is never taxed to you.

Points to check: a qualified appraisal is required for non-publicly traded property over $5,000 (IRC 170(f)(11)); ordinary income recapture, such as equipment from a cost segregation study, reduces the deduction (IRC 170(e)(1)(A)); a gift of an interest that carries debt is treated as part sale, part gift (Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2); the sponsor must consent to a transfer; and many charities decline illiquid interests or leveraged real estate, since debt-financed income can be taxable to a charity (IRC 514).

Giving only the income from an interest while keeping the interest generally earns no deduction (IRC 170(f)(3)) and the income stays taxable to you. Giving an undivided share of the whole interest can work.

A gift soon after the exchange also puts the exchange at risk, because IRC 1031(a)(1) requires intent to hold for investment; allow a real holding period.

Fund a CRT with an unleveraged trust interest. A trust interest held after an exchange can be contributed to a CRT, which later sells and pays you, with the carried-over gain taxed through the four tiers. The same prearranged-sale and debt problems apply, so a leveraged interest is generally a poor fit.

When does each one win?

No option wins in every case. Match your facts to the row.

Your situationUsually winsWhy
No debt, a real giving goal, and you want lifetime incomeCharitable remainder trustTax-exempt sale, a deduction, and payments for life or up to 20 years
Mortgage on the propertyCharitable UPREITThe trust's loan can replace the debt; a CRT or outright gift handles debt poorly
Heirs matter and you want to keep most of the valueCharitable UPREIT, giving only partThe part you keep can pass with a stepped-up basis (IRC 1014)
A replacement property fell through on day 40 and you want a backupCharitable UPREIT, step 1A Delaware statutory trust interest can be identified as a backup and can absorb boot
Top bracket, no debt, no income needed, charity will take the propertyOutright giftFair market value deduction, no gain, and no trust or sponsor to manage
Charity will not take real estate, but would take a securityCharitable UPREITThe gift is units or a trust interest, not the building
You want income and heirs to be made wholeCRT plus a wealth replacement trustHeirs are replaced by a separate irrevocable life insurance trust, at its own cost
You want control, cash and flexibilityNone of the threeCompare an installment sale or a taxable sale

This is a screen, not advice. A single mortgage, a 1245 recapture figure or a private foundation as the donee can reverse a row.

Case studies: when does each one win?

Hypothetical illustrations only, not a promise of results. Round numbers. Federal tax is figured at 20% long-term capital gain plus 3.8% net investment income tax (23.8%), and 25% plus 3.8% (28.8%) on unrecaptured Section 1250 gain where depreciation applies; top rates are applied to all gain, so real results will differ.

State tax is not included and would add to every sale figure. Selling costs, appraisal and legal fees are ignored. Nothing assumes an investment return.

Case 1: the charitable remainder trust wins

Situation. A 72-year-old widow owns a free-and-clear four-plex worth $2,000,000 with an adjusted basis of $300,000, of which $250,000 of the gain is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. She wants lifetime income, likes her church and a hospital foundation, and her children are financially comfortable.

Why the others lose. A 1031 exchange keeps assets she does not need to pass on and adds sponsor risk and illiquidity. An outright gift pays her nothing. A charitable UPREIT adds a second and third step she has no use for.

Sell and pay the taxCharitable remainder trust (5% unitrust)
Federal tax at the saleAbout $417,100 ($250,000 at 28.8% plus $1,450,000 at 23.8%)None at the sale
Amount working after the saleAbout $1,582,900$2,000,000
Year-one paymentDepends on what the $1,582,900 earns; 5% would be about $79,000$100,000 (5% of the trust's value, recalculated yearly)
Income tax deductionNonePresent value of the charity's remainder; for illustration about 50%, or $1,000,000, set by IRS tables and the Section 7520 rate
Using the deductionNot applicableLimited to 30% of AGI with a five-year carryforward: at $150,000 of AGI that is $45,000 a year, so only about $270,000 of the $1,000,000 is usable and the rest expires
What her children receive from this assetThe remaining portfolioNothing; the remainder goes to charity

Takeaway. The CRT puts about $417,000 more to work for her income and spreads the gain across her payments, but the deduction may be mostly wasted at her income, and the asset is gone from her family.

Talk to Hans about your own version of this case.

Case 2: the charitable UPREIT wins

Situation. A 65-year-old couple owns a $3,000,000 industrial building with a $1,000,000 mortgage and a $500,000 adjusted basis, of which $600,000 of the gain is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. They want to keep the income, leave something to their children with a stepped-up basis, and give a little each year.

Why the others lose. A CRT is a poor fit for mortgaged property. An outright gift of a mortgaged building is a bargain sale and most charities decline it. A sale triggers the tax now.

SellCharitable UPREIT
Gain$2,500,000$2,500,000, deferred
Federal tax nowAbout $625,000 ($600,000 at 28.8% plus $1,900,000 at 23.8%)$0 if every 1031 rule is met
Equity working after step 1About $1,375,000 ($2,000,000 less $625,000 tax)About $2,000,000, with replacement debt of $1,000,000 in the Delaware statutory trusts
Step 2NoneA 721 contribution into operating partnership units; no 45-day or 180-day clock, but no more 1031 exchanges
Step 3NoneAfter a real holding period, give units each year, for example $100,000 of units a year for five years; the deduction is the fair market value of the units, within 30% of AGI. Debt allocated to units given is treated as sale proceeds, so gifts from less leveraged holdings are cleaner
Deferred gain on units kept at deathNot applicableGenerally erased by the step-up (IRC 1014)

Takeaway. The UPREIT keeps the full equity invested, replaces the debt, and turns future gifts into units instead of cash, while the children can still receive a stepped-up basis. The price is illiquidity, fees, sponsor risk and a taxable exit if they ever redeem.

Talk to Hans about your own version of this case.

Case 3: the outright gift wins

Situation. A 60-year-old executive in the 37% bracket with $800,000 of adjusted gross income owns $1,000,000 of debt-free raw land held for 20 years with a $100,000 basis. She is charitable, does not need income, and a local land trust (a public charity) will accept the land.

Why the others lose. A CRT pays her income she does not need and costs more to run. A charitable UPREIT is built for leveraged real estate she does not have.

Sell, then give the cashGive the land
Federal tax on the gainAbout $214,200 (23.8% of $900,000)None
What charity receivesAbout $785,800$1,000,000
Deduction$785,800 of cash$1,000,000 at fair market value; no related-use test for real estate
Using the deduction30% of AGI for appreciated property, or 60% for cash gifts to a public charity30% of $800,000 is $240,000 a year, so about five years including carryforward
Approximate tax value of the deductionAbout $275,000 (35% effective, after the 2/37 reduction)About $350,000 (35% effective)
Your approximate net costAbout $725,000 ($1,000,000 value, less $275,000)About $650,000 ($1,000,000 value, less $350,000)

Takeaway. With no income need and no debt, the outright gift gives charity more at a lower net cost. It needs a qualified appraisal, Form 8283 Section B, and a charity that will accept the land.

Talk to Hans about your own version of this case.

Case 4: a CRT plus a wealth replacement trust wins

Situation. A 68-year-old business owner has a free-and-clear $5,000,000 building with a $1,000,000 basis, of which $500,000 of the gain is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. She wants income and wants her children made whole.

Why the others lose. A charitable UPREIT does not give her the same income stream from a diversified portfolio and keeps her property risk. A plain CRT leaves her children with nothing from the building. An outright gift pays no income.

SellCRT plus irrevocable life insurance trust
Federal tax at the saleAbout $977,000 ($500,000 at 28.8% plus $3,500,000 at 23.8%)None at the sale
Amount working after the saleAbout $4,023,000$5,000,000 in the CRT
Year-one payment (5%)About $201,000 on $4,023,000$250,000
HeirsThe remaining portfolioA policy owned by the trust, intended to replace about $5,000,000; premium is a hypothetical $100,000 a year, and real premiums depend on age, health and product and could be far higher
Income after premiumAbout $201,000, before income taxAbout $150,000, before income tax on the payments
CharityNothingReceives the CRT remainder

Takeaway. The plan works only if she is insurable at a premium she can afford, so underwriting comes first and the CRT is funded after the policy is approved. Death benefits are generally not subject to income tax (IRC 101(a)), and the trust is meant to keep them out of her estate, but the premium cost is real and the Big Sale Tax Analysis does not recommend a product.

Talk to Hans about your own version of this case.

Case 5: just selling wins

Situation. A 58-year-old owns a $400,000 rental with a $300,000 basis, no mortgage and no giving goal, and needs the cash for a down payment within 90 days.

Why the others lose. A CRT or a charitable UPREIT costs more in legal, appraisal and sponsor fees than the tax saved on a $100,000 gain, and neither fits a need for cash.

Sell
Federal tax on a $100,000 gainAbout $23,800 at 23.8%, less if parts of the gain fall in lower brackets
Cash after taxAbout $376,200 before selling costs and state tax

Takeaway. When the gain is small, you need cash, and giving is not a goal, the trust fees and illiquidity of the other paths are not worth it. An installment sale could still spread the tax.

Talk to Hans about your own version of this case.

Common confusions, in plain English

  1. A charitable UPREIT is three steps. In plain English: swap the building for shares, keep the income, and give shares when you want. Step 1 is a 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust, step 2 is a 721 contribution into operating partnership units, and step 3 is giving units to charity.
  2. Deferred is not eliminated. A 1031 exchange defers the gain. It is gone only on units you give away, or when heirs receive a stepped-up basis at your death. A charitable remainder trust's sale itself is not taxed, but the gain still reaches you as payments.
  3. The UPREIT trap. Operating partnership units are not REIT stock. If the units are converted or redeemed, or the REIT sells the property you contributed, the deferred gain can come due, and you cannot 1031 out of units.
  4. A deduction is not a refund. A $2,000,000 deduction at 37% is worth at most about $740,000 of federal tax, and about $700,000 after the 2026 2/37 reduction. The 30% of AGI cap and five-year carryforward mean you would need about $1,100,000 of income each year to use it all, so a retiree with modest income may lose much of it.
  5. CRT payments are taxed in four tiers. Ordinary income comes out first, then capital gain, then tax-exempt income, then return of principal (IRC 664(b)).
  6. Timing decides everything. Fund the CRT or give the property before a binding sale contract. A 1031 exchange has a 45-day identification and a 180-day closing window.
  7. The related-use rule is for art, not real estate. Real estate given to a public charity is deductible at fair market value whatever the charity does with it.
  8. What do my kids get?
OptionWhat your children receive
Outright giftNothing from that property
Charitable remainder trustNothing from the trust; the remainder goes to charity, unless a replacement trust is set up
CRT plus insurance trustA life insurance death benefit, if you are insurable and pay the premiums
Charitable UPREITThe units you keep, generally with a stepped-up basis
Charitable lead trustWhat is left after the charity's payments end
Just sellingThe after-tax proceeds

Who does each path fit?

An outright gift tends to fit an owner with debt-free property and no need for income, whose chosen charity will actually accept it, and who wants the simplest deduction.

A CRT tends to fit an owner with a large gain on debt-free property, who already wants to give to charity, wants lifetime income and diversification, and is comfortable that heirs get nothing from that asset.

A 1031 into a Delaware statutory trust tends to fit an owner with a mortgage, a strong wish to pass wealth to heirs with a step-up, and willingness to give up control and liquidity. It does not fit someone who needs the money back on a schedule.

A 721 step tends to fit an exhausted landlord who wants no more deadlines and accepts a taxable exit if units are ever redeemed.

Neither fits a seller who wants cash, flexibility and control. Compare a installment sale and a donor-advised fund too.

What does the choice look like in numbers?

Illustration, not a projection. Land worth $3,000,000 with a $500,000 basis, no debt and no depreciation, so a $2,500,000 gain. Assume the top federal rates of 20% plus 3.8% net investment income tax and ignore state tax.

  • Cash sale: about $595,000 of federal tax in the year of sale, leaving about $2,405,000 to invest.
  • Outright gift: a deduction for the full $3,000,000 value within the 30% of AGI limit with a five-year carryforward, no gain taxed, and no income to you.
  • CRT: $3,000,000 is invested after the trust sells. A 5% unitrust pays $150,000 in year one (5% of the trust's value, recalculated each year). The gain is taxed to you as the capital gain tier is paid out. A deduction applies for the present value of charity's remainder, and charity receives what remains.
  • 1031 into a Delaware statutory trust: $3,000,000 is reinvested and the $595,000 stays deferred. It comes due if you cash out, or goes away for heirs who receive a stepped-up basis at your death. Charity receives nothing unless you give it.

No outcome above assumes a rate of return, because none is promised by any sponsor or trustee. Mortgage, state tax, depreciation and your income change every number, which is what the analysis models.

Practitioner view: charitable UPREIT from a sponsor

A Delaware statutory trust sponsor's practical view on the charitable UPREIT, including how charities respond to gifts of trust interests and units, is being added to this page. If you advise sellers who are charitably inclined and would like to contribute, contact Big Sale Tax.

What to know

A CRT gives you a deduction, no tax on the sale itself and lifetime income, and in return it is irrevocable and its remainder belongs to charity.

A 1031 into a Delaware statutory trust keeps value for heirs and can replace debt, and in return costs control, liquidity and fees, and the gain comes back when you cash out. A 721 UPREIT step adds a taxable exit.

Charitable gifts of interests or units add a deduction but require appraisals, charity acceptance and careful timing. None of these removes the gain unless you hold until death or give the asset away.

Free PDF sheet

Your Big Sale Options

One page, eleven paths: cash, installment sale, 1031, Delaware statutory trust, Opportunity Zone, charitable remainder trust or charitable UPREIT, Section 121, QSBS, loss harvesting, bracket timing and moving states. What each does, who it fits, the trade-off, liquidity and the 2026 rule, plus four questions for your CPA.

Hans Goldstein
Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS

By entering your email you agree to receive this sheet and occasional educational emails from Hans Goldstein: Tax & Exit Planning. Unsubscribe anytime.

Installment sale + 1031 + ILIT: when is it a slam dunk?

For a large estate, a 1031 exchange, an installment sale and a trust-owned life insurance policy (an ILIT) can work together. It tends to win when most of these are true (2026 figures: the federal estate tax exemption is $15,000,000 per person, $30,000,000 for a married couple):

  1. Your estate is clearly over the line: a projected estate tax bill of $10,000,000 or more.
  2. You are married, age 50 to 60, in preferred health or better. At 75 or older, single, or in a rated health class it usually does not win.
  3. One separate property has stuck (suspended) passive losses at least as big as its gain.
  4. That property earns little: low cap rate, slow growth.
  5. You would sell or borrow anyway, or you do not have the cash on hand to pay the premiums.

Four or five true? Run the numbers. Enter your own estate and ages below, or open the full calculator. Estimates from published rates, not a quote or advice; your CPA and attorney decide.

Open the calculator on this page

Frequently asked questions

Is there a related-use rule when I donate real estate?
No. The related-use rule and the three-year recapture rule apply to tangible personal property such as art. Long-term appreciated real estate given to a public charity is generally deductible at fair market value, within AGI limits, whatever the charity does with it.
What happens if I donate real estate with a mortgage?
It is treated as part sale and part gift (a bargain sale). You recognize gain on the part treated as sold, and most charities decline mortgaged property.
What is a charitable UPREIT?
A plan that combines a 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust, a 721 contribution into UPREIT operating partnership units, and a gift of units or an undivided share to charity. It defers gain until the gift and then avoids tax on the part given. It requires an appraisal, a willing charity and counsel.
Is a charitable remainder trust better than a 1031 exchange?
Not on tax alone. A 1031 exchange defers the gain and lets heirs keep the asset, possibly with a stepped-up basis. A charitable remainder trust gives a deduction and income, but the remainder goes to charity. The choice is mostly about whether you want to benefit charity.
Can I put a 1031 exchange into a charitable remainder trust?
The trust is tax-exempt, so it does not need a 1031 exchange. The usual routes are to fund the trust with the property before a binding sale, or to contribute an unleveraged interest you acquired in an exchange. Prearranged sales and debt are the main risks.
Can you donate a Delaware statutory trust interest to charity?
Yes, if the sponsor allows the transfer and a charity accepts it. An outright gift of long-term appreciated property is generally deductible at fair market value within AGI limits, and a qualified appraisal is required over $5,000. Debt and recapture can reduce the benefit.
Can a charitable remainder trust take property with a mortgage?
Generally it is a poor fit. Debt can cause bargain-sale income, self-dealing and unrelated business income, which carries a 100% excise tax inside the trust. Paying the loan off first or using another strategy is typical.
What happens to the deferred gain in a Delaware statutory trust?
It stays deferred while you hold or exchange again. It is taxed when you cash out, and heirs generally receive a stepped-up basis if you hold until death (IRC 1014).
What is the downside of a 721 UPREIT exchange?
You can never 1031 again, redeeming units for cash or shares is taxable, and redemption can be limited. See the 721 exchange guide.
Do heirs get anything from a charitable remainder trust?
Not from that asset: the remainder goes to charity. Some plans add a wealth replacement irrevocable life insurance trust, which has its own cost and underwriting.
How is a charitable remainder trust payout taxed?
In four tiers under IRC 664(b): ordinary income, capital gain, other income, then return of principal. The sale gain is taxed as it is paid out over time.
What is the AGI limit on donating appreciated real estate or trust interests?
For long-term appreciated property given to a public charity, the limit is 30% of adjusted gross income, with a five-year carryforward. The limit is 20% for gifts to which a private non-operating foundation is the remainder beneficiary.
Can I give just the income from a Delaware statutory trust interest to charity?
Generally that earns no income tax deduction under IRC 170(f)(3), and the income remains taxable to you. A gift of an undivided portion of the whole interest can qualify.
Does a 721 UPREIT step avoid tax permanently?
No. It defers the gain. Units redeemed for cash or shares are taxable, though heirs can receive a stepped-up basis if you hold until death.
How Hans helps: the Big Sale Tax Analysis models this path side by side with every other option for your sale and ends with a written recommendation. See the analysis.
Next step

Know your number before you sign.

Start with a free scope call: a short call to see whether the Big Sale Tax Analysis is worth it for your sale. No obligation.

Prefer email? Request the analysis by email.

You talk to Hans Goldstein. Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS.

Call Hans: 213-340-2018Book a time