Request the analysis Book a free scope call
Talk to Hans before you pick one
Which charitable option fits a real estate or business sale?
Charitable planning can remove or spread the tax on a large gain, but every option gives something up: control, income, liquidity or what your heirs receive. Start with three questions. Do you want income back from the asset? Is there debt on it? How much do you want your heirs, as opposed to charity, to keep?
| Option | You get income | Handles debt | Heirs keep the asset | Deduction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charitable remainder trust | Yes | Poorly | No | Present value of remainder |
| Charitable UPREIT | On what you keep | Yes | Part you keep | Fair market value of units given |
| Outright gift of real estate | No | Poorly (bargain sale) | No | Fair market value |
| Bargain sale to charity | Cash for part | Yes, as part sale | No | Value above the price |
| Charitable gift annuity | Yes, fixed | Poorly | No | Value above the fixed payments |
| Donor-advised fund | No | Poorly | No | Fair market value |
| Charitable lead trust | No, charity first | Poorly | Yes, remainder | Depends on type |
| Retained life estate | Use of the property | Poorly | No | Present value of remainder |
| Pooled income fund | Yes, variable | No (cash or securities) | No | Present value of remainder |
| Private foundation | No | Poorly | No, but family can run it | Often limited to basis |
| Conservation easement | You keep the land | Needs lender consent | Yes, restricted | Value lost, with limits |
| CRT plus insurance trust | Yes | Poorly | Replaced by a policy | Present value of remainder |
All the charitable options, with a page for each
Start with the side-by-side: Charitable options for a big property or business sale, compared and when each wins.
- Charitable remainder trust
- Charitable UPREIT (721 exchange, then gift units)
- Charitable UPREIT vs charitable remainder trust
- Bargain sale to charity
- Charitable gift annuity
- Donor-advised fund
- Charitable lead trust
- Charitable lead trust vs charitable remainder trust
- Pooled income fund
- Charitable LLC
- Gifting shares before a sale
- Conservation easement
Common confusions, in plain English
- A charitable UPREIT is three steps. In plain English: swap the building for shares, keep the income, and give shares when you want. Step 1 is a 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust, step 2 is a 721 contribution into operating partnership units, and step 3 is giving units to charity.
- Deferred is not eliminated. A 1031 exchange defers the gain. It is gone only on units you give away, or when heirs receive a stepped-up basis at your death. A charitable remainder trust's sale itself is not taxed, but the gain still reaches you as payments.
- The UPREIT trap. Operating partnership units are not REIT stock. If the units are converted or redeemed, or the REIT sells the property you contributed, the deferred gain can come due, and you cannot 1031 out of units.
- A deduction is not a refund. A $2,000,000 deduction at 37% is worth at most about $740,000 of federal tax, and about $700,000 after the 2026 2/37 reduction. The 30% of AGI cap and five-year carryforward mean you would need about $1,100,000 of income each year to use it all, so a retiree with modest income may lose much of it.
- CRT payments are taxed in four tiers. Ordinary income comes out first, then capital gain, then tax-exempt income, then return of principal (IRC 664(b)).
- Timing decides everything. Fund the CRT or give the property before a binding sale contract. A 1031 exchange has a 45-day identification and a 180-day closing window.
- The related-use rule is for art, not real estate. Real estate given to a public charity is deductible at fair market value whatever the charity does with it.
- What do my kids get?
| Option | What your children receive |
|---|---|
| Outright gift | Nothing from that property |
| Charitable remainder trust | Nothing from the trust; the remainder goes to charity, unless a replacement trust is set up |
| CRT plus insurance trust | A life insurance death benefit, if you are insurable and pay the premiums |
| Charitable UPREIT | The units you keep, generally with a stepped-up basis |
| Charitable lead trust | What is left after the charity's payments end |
| Just selling | The after-tax proceeds |
Charitable remainder trust (CRAT, CRUT, NIMCRUT, flip CRUT)
What it is. An irrevocable, tax-exempt trust you fund before a sale. The trust sells, reinvests the full price and pays you for life or up to 20 years, then the remainder goes to charity.
A CRAT pays a fixed amount, a CRUT a percentage of a yearly revalued balance, a NIMCRUT only trust income with make-up, and a flip CRUT starts as a NIMCRUT and flips to a CRUT after a trigger such as the sale of an illiquid asset.
When it wins. You own debt-free, low-basis property, want lifetime income and a deduction, and are comfortable that the remainder goes to charity.
Watch for. A binding sale before funding (the gain is yours), mortgages, S corporation stock, unrelated business income inside the trust, and the 2026 deduction trims.
Key rule. IRC 664; payout 5% to 50%; remainder at least 10% at funding; payments taxed in four tiers (IRC 664(b)); 100% excise tax on unrelated business taxable income (IRC 664(c)(2)).
Charitable remainder trust guide
Charitable UPREIT
What it is. A 1031 exchange with the option to give later. The sale-day tax benefit is ordinary 1031 deferral; the charitable benefit arises only when you later give appreciated trust interests or units. The steps are a 1031 exchange into a Delaware statutory trust, a 721 contribution into REIT operating partnership units, and then a gift of units or an undivided share to charity.
When it wins. You have a mortgage, want to keep income and leave heirs a stepped-up basis, and a charity would take a security but not a building.
Watch for. Giving too soon after the exchange (IRC 1031(a)(1) intent to hold; no bright line, often a two-year comfort period by analogy to IRC 1031(f)), debt in gifted interests treated as a bargain sale (Rev. Rul. 75-194, Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2) and debt-financed income to the charity (IRC 514), appraisal discounts, charities and DAFs that will not accept the interests, sponsor loads and commissions, illiquidity, and a taxable exit on units you redeem.
Key rule. IRC 1031 and Rev. Rul. 2004-86, IRC 721, IRC 170 and IRC 1014.
Charitable UPREIT vs charitable remainder trust vs outright gift, with four case studies
Outright gift of appreciated real estate
What it is. Give the property itself to a public charity.
When it wins. Debt-free property, a strong giving goal, no need for income, and a charity that will accept it.
Watch for. A mortgage makes it a bargain sale, a binding sale before the gift taxes you, and many charities decline real estate. A private foundation as donee limits the deduction to basis.
Key rule. Long-term real estate to a public charity is deductible at fair market value with no related-use test (the related-use rule applies to tangible personal property such as art); 30% of AGI, or 50% if you elect basis, with a five-year carryforward; qualified appraisal and Form 8283 Section B.
Bargain sale to charity
What it is. Sell the property to a charity for less than its value. The difference is a gift.
When it wins. You want some cash, the property has debt, and the charity will buy it.
Watch for. You recognize gain on the part treated as sold, and the deduction is reduced by any ordinary income element.
Key rule. IRC 170(e)(2) and 1011(b); Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2 allocate basis between the sale and the gift.
Charitable gift annuity
What it is. You give property to a charity in return for its promise to pay you a fixed amount for life.
When it wins. You are older, want a fixed payment with no investment management, and your charity offers one for real estate.
Watch for. The payment depends on the charity's ability to pay, part of the gain is taxed as a bargain sale, and you cannot change the payment.
Key rule. IRC 170 and 1011(b) with Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2; the gain is generally reported over your life expectancy when you are the annuitant.
Donor-advised fund
What it is. Give appreciated property, sometimes real estate or private interests, to a sponsoring public charity and recommend grants later.
When it wins. You want the deduction now and flexible giving over years, and the sponsor accepts the asset.
Watch for. Irrevocable, no income back, sponsors usually accept real estate or units only after due diligence, and fees apply.
Key rule. Fair market value deduction for long-term property within 30% of AGI; the sponsor has legal control and you only advise.
Charitable lead trust (CLAT and CLUT)
What it is. The reverse of a CRT: charity is paid first for a term, then the remainder goes to your heirs.
When it wins. You do not need the income, want to pass assets to heirs with less gift or estate tax, and have a long horizon.
Watch for. A non-grantor trust gives no income tax deduction to you, a grantor trust gives one up front but taxes you on the trust's income, and a sale inside the trust is taxed.
Key rule. IRC 170(f)(2)(B) and 2522(c)(2) for the charitable interest; IRC 673 and 671 for grantor status.
Charitable lead trust guide and lead vs remainder
Retained life estate in a home or farm
What it is. Give the remainder interest in your personal residence or farm to charity and keep the right to use it for life.
When it wins. You want to keep living on or farming the property and give it later.
Watch for. The deduction is only the present value of the remainder, you stay responsible for upkeep, and it covers a personal residence or farm only.
Key rule. IRC 170(f)(3)(B)(i); valuation uses IRS tables and the Section 7520 rate.
Compare with a charitable remainder trust
Pooled income fund
What it is. Give property to a charity's shared fund and receive a share of the fund's income for life.
When it wins. You want modest variable income and a small charity offers it.
Watch for. Few charities run one, and it generally takes cash or securities, not real estate.
Key rule. IRC 642(c)(5) and 170(f)(2)(A).
Private foundation
What it is. Your own charity, with family control over grants.
When it wins. You want family control and a long giving horizon, and the gift is cash or publicly traded stock.
Watch for. Deductions for appreciated property are generally limited to basis and 20% of AGI, and the foundation has excise taxes, a 5% payout rule and self-dealing limits.
Key rule. IRC 170(e)(1)(B)(ii), 170(b)(1)(D), 4940, 4941 and 4942.
Compare with a charitable remainder trust
Conservation easement
What it is. Give a permanent restriction on land to a qualified land trust or agency and keep ownership.
When it wins. You own land with real conservation value and want to keep farming or holding it.
Watch for. The deduction is the value lost, not a sale. Syndicated deals are the problem: the IRS lists certain syndicated easements as a listed transaction (Notice 2017-10), and IRC 170(h)(7) from SECURE 2.0 caps a partnership's deduction at 2.5 times the investor's outlay with limited exceptions. Never buy a deduction.
Key rule. IRC 170(h); the deduction is generally limited to 50% of AGI, or 100% for qualified farmers and ranchers, with a 15-year carryforward.
Syndicated conservation easement guide
CRT plus a wealth replacement trust
What it is. A CRT for income and charity, plus an irrevocable life insurance trust that holds a policy meant to replace the value for your children.
When it wins. You want income and you want your heirs made whole.
Watch for. You must be insurable at an affordable premium, premiums come out of your payments, and the policy should be approved before the CRT is funded. Big Sale Tax does not recommend a product.
Key rule. IRC 664 for the trust, IRC 101(a) for death benefits that are generally not subject to income tax, and estate inclusion rules for the policy owner.
Irrevocable life insurance trust calculator and case study 4
What to know
No charitable option removes the tax for free: each exchanges control, income, liquidity or an inheritance for a deduction or a deferral. Debt and a binding sale before the gift are the two most common ways these plans fail. Work with your own attorney and CPA on documents, appraisals and the deduction.
Your Big Sale Options
One page, eleven paths: cash, installment sale, 1031, Delaware statutory trust, Opportunity Zone, charitable remainder trust or charitable UPREIT, Section 121, QSBS, loss harvesting, bracket timing and moving states. What each does, who it fits, the trade-off, liquidity and the 2026 rule, plus four questions for your CPA.
Installment sale + 1031 + ILIT: when is it a slam dunk?
For a large estate, a 1031 exchange, an installment sale and a trust-owned life insurance policy (an ILIT) can work together. It tends to win when most of these are true (2026 figures: the federal estate tax exemption is $15,000,000 per person, $30,000,000 for a married couple):
- Your estate is clearly over the line: a projected estate tax bill of $10,000,000 or more.
- You are married, age 50 to 60, in preferred health or better. At 75 or older, single, or in a rated health class it usually does not win.
- One separate property has stuck (suspended) passive losses at least as big as its gain.
- That property earns little: low cap rate, slow growth.
- You would sell or borrow anyway, or you do not have the cash on hand to pay the premiums.
Four or five true? Run the numbers. Enter your own estate and ages below, or open the full calculator. Estimates from published rates, not a quote or advice; your CPA and attorney decide.
Open the calculator on this page
Frequently asked questions
What are the charitable tax strategies for selling real estate?
How do I avoid capital gains tax on real estate by giving to charity?
Is a charitable remainder trust better than donating real estate directly?
Can a charity take real estate with a mortgage?
What is a charitable UPREIT?
What is the AGI limit on donating appreciated real estate?
Is a conservation easement a good way to cut tax on a sale?
Can I give real estate to a donor-advised fund?
How do heirs get replaced when I use a charitable remainder trust?
Sources
- IRC 170, charitable deductions (Cornell LII)
- IRC 664, charitable remainder trusts (Cornell LII)
- IRC 642(c), pooled income funds (Cornell LII)
- IRC 1011, bargain sale basis (Cornell LII)
- Treas. Reg. 1.1011-2, bargain sales to charity (eCFR)
- IRC 4940, private foundation excise tax (Cornell LII)
- IRC 68, 2/37 reduction (Cornell LII)
- Notice 2017-10, syndicated conservation easements (IRS)
- Charitable remainder trusts (IRS)
- Form 8283 and instructions, noncash charitable contributions (IRS)
- Rev. Rul. 2004-86, Delaware statutory trust (IRS)
Updated November 21, 2026. Education only, not legal or tax advice.
Keep comparing
Charitable remainder trust
Give appreciated property to a trust before the sale, let the trust sell it, take an income stream for life or up to 20 years, and leave the rest to charity.
ReadCharitable lead trust
Charity gets the payments first, family or you get what is left: how a grantor lead trust can offset a big sale year, and how a non-grantor lead trust moves wea
ReadBargain sale to charity
Sell property to a charity below market value: part sale, part gift, with basis split between the two and a deduction for the gift part.
ReadCharitable gift annuity
A contract with a charity: you give property, the charity pays you a fixed amount for life, and part of the transfer is a deductible gift.
ReadDonor-advised fund (appreciated assets)
Give appreciated stock, real estate or business interests to a donor-advised fund before a sale: no gain to you, a fair market value deduction, grants later.
ReadPooled income fund
Give appreciated assets to a charity's shared trust, skip the gain on the transfer, and receive a share of the fund's income for life.
ReadKnow your number before you sign.
Start with a free scope call: a short call to see whether the Big Sale Tax Analysis is worth it for your sale. No obligation.
Prefer email? Request the analysis by email.
You talk to Hans Goldstein. Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the IRS.